Ok, back in
this entry, I was talking about "The Gospel According to Twilight" (which, by the way, I found some thoughts on at a few websites that I haven't listened to yet, but no book yet), and also my annoyance with religious people who haven't read it screaming "evil!". So, today we have the first part of that, in which I will argue back at the criticisms, and hopefully soon part 2, where I will talk about theological/moral/religious issues in Twilight.
I think everyone who pays attention to my journal knows I love Twilight in a "wow, this is messed up, let us giggle" sort of way, not a "ZOMG TWILIGHT HAVE YOU READ IT YET? WHY NOT? WHAT IS WRONG WITH YOU?" or an "I WISH EDWARD WAS REAL AND WOULD BITE ME!" kinda way. So if you wanna criticize the creepy stalker aspect of Twilight, groovy, I'm with you. Just also criticize every romantic comedy where at the end the couple realize that this person who has treated them horribly all the way through is really the perfect person for them and they are in LOVE, so they should drop everything and run to them for a life of bickering and possible abuse. Rah.
What I don't like is people who haven't read it and just know bits and pieces of it from hearing people who HAVE read it making accusations that just aren't justifiable, and then yelling at people who read it. Not nice. Or smart. Just doesn't do much for their position in general. So, moving on...
It has vampires in it!Yeah, so? Narnia has unicorns. Mythical creatures, mythical creatures. Can we move on?
No, but vampires are bad!They are? Not really. Maybe in a few movies/books/shows where they are the bad guys and get fought off. In quite a bit of entertainment, they are people with ISSUES who have to overcome them to be better people. You know, like every human has to fight off their darker impulses, and like people in almost every religion I know of are supposed to strive to be better than they are naturally.
But vampires are demons! Demons can't NOT be evil!Ok, what's a demon? Do you even know? Because I don't. It doesn't say anywhere for certain, there are different views in different cultures, and taking the one I grew up with (so the one I assume is common in conservative Christian churches, though I could be wrong), they are angels who went bad. If an angel can go bad, why can't a fallen angel go good? See, there's this thing called repentance, where when creatures who were good do something bad they can admit that and be sorry and come back and God will forgive them. Groovy.
But beyond that, vampires aren't demons, necessarily. Don't put Buffyverse on the whole rest of vampire lore. And yeah, I'm sure that's not the only series that said they were demons, but definitely not all do. And in terms of Twilight, that seems to be how Edward sees himself, but he is proven to be wrong on a LOT throughout Twilight. Basically he's just a whiny self-hating pessimist who will only see himself and his kind in the worst possible way. What vampires actually SEEM to be in Twilight, is people infected with an illness. They get venom/spit injected into them, and just like rabies will make you go crazy and attack people, that's what happens to them. Crazy illness that makes them crave BLOOD and live a long time. But, luckily, they retain sanity and the illness fades a bit over time so that sanity can take over again, and they CAN resist the illness and stop themselves from getting too carried away, with lots and lots of work. I think we can all agree that if rabid animals could stop themselves from biting us, we would want them to. Yay!
Edward's reasoning for not sleeping with Bella is that he thinks he will go to Hell if he breaks the commandments. Being saved isn't about what you do, it's about God forgiving you!And yet you had a problem with Edward being forgiven? Ok, I'll be fair, maybe these are not the same people who had that criticism, I can't remember. Anyway. Who gets to decide what "being saved" means? That's not even an idea most faiths have. Everything that doesn't fit your point of view on that has to be banned? But hey, maybe this is really just saying that people who do believe this would prefer they and their children didn't read stuff that teaches something other than their faith, I can see that. But Twilight DOESN'T teach that. Again, Edward is wrong a lot. No one else seems to take him very seriously when he says this stuff. So, relax, you can still tell your daughters that if a boy ever says he won't sleep with her because he doesn't want her to go to hell, he doesn't know what he's talking about and she should jump in bed with him anyway. Wait, was that not the lesson you were getting at there?
Also, if it HAD actually taught that, this is something you can talk over with your children! No, you shouldn't just read and accept things that teach something you don't believe. You should never just read and accept ANYTHING! But you don't have to ban it, either. Read it if you want, discuss it, have an understanding about what other views are out there and why you believe what you do, so that when your kid goes off to college and finds out the whole world isn't like your house and church, s/he won't be confused by other ideas and think everything s/he encounters is true because that's how it worked at home!
But they're still disobeying her dad by REALLY sleeping (the zzz kind) together every night through 5 blankets. He probably wouldn't like that she had a boy in her room. And then they lie to him after she is turned.Yeah, they do. And that's bad. And is another think you should DISCUSS with your children, rather than hiding it and pretending the world is a perfect place and no one ever does anything you disagree with.
Bella wants to become a vampire. That's like embracing evil and choosing to hurt people.Yeah, you know how we said Edward is wrong a lot? And also dangerous and stalkery? Well, Bella's crazy enough to LIKE that. She's not exactly a role model. And she doesn't have to be. Bad example characters can be as useful as good example characters. TALK TO YOUR CHILDREN. Are we sensing a theme here yet? Maybe?
What about that birth scene? Why would she be so devoted to a monster that's going to rip her apart? And do I really want my kids reading something that...gory?Have you read the Bible lately? If you see your kids reading it, do you follow them around making sure they're not reading the sexy parts, or the violent parts, or the gross parts? That's sort of a part of life. You don't have to hide it, just deal with it and talk about it. And in case you didn't know? Birth is messy. And painful. No one WANTS to go through that. But, Bella LOVES her baby and doesn't feel the pain and grossness are enough that she should give it up. So, if by some crazy unseen circumstances while your daughter is "out with friends" that you know are totally innocent and trustworthy because you never let her see anything less than that, she becomes pregnant, she might not immediately jump to "OH THIS IS GOING TO HURT AND BE YUCKY, I SHOULD GET AN ABORTION!" She might think about it being her child, and that you went through that process to have her, and it might be worth it.
I think that's all I've got. At the least, it's all I've got right now, because I told myself that I would finally stop being lazy and get dressed at 10:30. Please excuse the sarcasm. See ya.